my eyes tear a lot therefore I always have issues with my eye liner smudging, one of my coworkers suggested Almay eyeliner and I was kind of skeptical because I'm more of a department store make-up girl versus a drug store make-up girl, however I purchased the Almay eyeliner and it came with their "dial up" mascara, when I tell you these two products work wonders!!! they are my new fav no smudging and my lashes look so full and rich. I highly recommend them both so don't under estimate the drug store brands :-)